Contract to Hire Is the Best Way to Hire Today

Key Takeaways

Contract to hire meaning: An employment arrangement that lets you bring on talent for a fixed period with the possibility of transitioning them to a permanent role. It's a trial run for both employer and employee. Contract to hire has also been referred to as “temp to hire” in the past.
Contract to hire offers a strategic solution to manage hiring uncertainty and build a more resilient workforce.
Benefits of this hiring model to employers include reduced risk, flexibility, cost savings, improved hiring decisions, and stronger teams.
Best practices for leveraging contract to hire include developing a clear offer letter, providing an effective onboarding process, and considering a staffing agency partner to manage the contract period and conversion.

The current hiring market is fraught with unknowns. Economic anxieties, political shifts, and disruptive innovations are making the employment market increasingly unpredictable. And the rapid pace of change in technologies and skills is creating a sense of uncertainty in hiring decisions. In this climate, filling permanent positions can feel like a gamble, leaving many companies hesitant to hire.

But what if there was a way to bridge the gap between your staffing needs and the risks of a full-time hire? Contract to hire, also known as temp to hire, is an often-overlooked strategy that addresses this need. In this post, we’ll break down the contract to hire model, explore its advantages, and help you decide if it’s right for your business.

Contract to hire meaning

Before we dive into the benefits, let’s first cover what is contract to hire. At its core, contract to hire is an employment arrangement where you bring on a new hire to fill a specific role, initially on a temporary basis. This temporary period is defined by a contract with a set duration, typically ranging from three months to a year. The key differentiator here is the built-in possibility of transitioning this temporary employee into a permanent role at the end of the contract, contingent on successful performance and mutual agreement. This structure offers a trial period for both employer and employee to assess fit for the role and team and ensure a smooth long-term working relationship.

What is contract to hire vs. traditional hiring?

Traditional hiring involves a lengthy recruitment process: crafting job descriptions, advertising positions, sifting through resumes and portfolios, conducting interviews (which can involve multiple rounds), and finally making an offer. This can be time-consuming and carries inherent risk. The new hire might not possess the skills you expected, or they might not mesh well with the team dynamic. Contract to hire mitigates these risks by allowing you to evaluate someone’s capabilities and fit within the daily workflow for a set period before extending a permanent offer. The trial period provides valuable insights you wouldn’t get from a traditional interview process.

What is contract to hire vs. temporary staffing?

Temporary staffing fills immediate needs, but those roles typically have pre-defined end dates and rarely convert to permanent positions. While temporary staffing offers flexibility, it doesn’t provide the long-term security some candidates seek. Contract to hire bridges this gap. It offers the flexibility of a temporary role but with the potential for a permanent position at the end of the contract. This makes contract to hire positions more appealing to qualified individuals seeking stability, potentially leading to a larger pool of talented candidates for your open role. A successful contract to hire arrangement often involves a smooth transition to permanent employment with discussions and paperwork initiated before the contract ends to ensure a seamless continuation.

Six reasons why contract to hire makes sense for employers

1. Budgetary constraints affecting hiring? Work around these constraints.

Challenge: Your permanent headcount budget may be limited, making a full-scale hiring process cost-prohibitive.
Benefit: Contract to hire can help companies facing budget challenges, as contract positions are typically paid for out of a different budget than full-time headcount. This work arrangement gives you more time to get budget approval for a permanent hire. In the meantime, there's less risk associated with onboarding and training someone who ultimately doesn't work out.

2. Economic environment creating hiring uncertainty? Reduce your risk.

Challenge: Economic factors may make companies hesitant to make permanent hires due to potential budget cuts.
Benefit: Contract to hire allows for a trial period before a permanent commitment. This reduces risk and provides valuable time to assess the candidate's fit within the current economic climate.

Think a tedious job interview process is the norm? It doesn't have to be.

By Jessica Gross 04.26.2023

Insights & Trends • Managing & Leading Teams • Recruiting & Hiring

3. Need immediate help? Get support now.

Challenge: The position needs to be filled quickly to address a critical workload or project deadline. The traditional hiring process can be too slow.
Benefit: A contractor can be brought in swiftly to provide immediate support, with the option to convert to permanent later.

4. Unsure about skill fit? Assess skills on the job.

Challenge: The role requires a specific skill set, but how can you be sure applicants possess those skills in a real-world setting? This has led to high turnover in the past.
Benefit: Contract to hire allows for a trial period. You can observe their skills and work ethic firsthand before committing to a permanent position.

5. Defining a brand new role? Gain real-world insights.

Challenge: Your company is creating a new role, but you're unclear on the specific skills and responsibilities needed.
Benefit: A contractor can help define the role's requirements through their work. Their real-world experience provides valuable insights before finalizing the permanent position description. You can then either convert your current contractor or recruit for the new role with greater confidence in what you're looking for.

6. Is culture fit crucial? Ensure a smooth integration.

Challenge: Your company culture is unique, and finding someone who thrives within that environment is essential. This has resulted in high turnover in the past.
Benefit: A contract worker can integrate into the team dynamics, allowing you to assess cultural fit before a permanent offer.

Four reasons why working contract to hire makes sense for employees

Finding fulfillment at work: Aligning your career and core values.

By Justin Dauer 08.17.2022

Career Advice • Insights & Trends • Remote Work

1. Getting a feel for a company’s work environment and culture

Challenge: It can often be difficult to get a real view into a company's true work style and team dynamics.
Benefit: Contract work allows new hires to experience the day-to-day interactions, communication styles, and overall work environment. This firsthand perspective can help them determine if the company culture meshes well with their personality and work style, reducing the risk of a bad fit in a permanent role.

2. Testing the waters before switching careers

Challenge: Career transitioners may feel unsure about how their skills will translate to a new career path.
Benefit: Working contract to hire can help talent gain relevant experience and assess fit in the new field. During the contract, they'll apply their transferable skills to new challenges and see if the daily tasks and responsibilities align with their interests and career goals. This hands-on experience can help them decide if pursuing a permanent role in this field is the right move.

3. Proving their value when it comes to a permanent offer

Challenge: During the interview process, it can be challenging for candidates to showcase their skills and demonstrate their value, which can translate to difficulty getting aligned during the offer stage.
Benefit: During the contract period, new hires have the opportunity to prove their worth and demonstrate their impact in the role. And for hiring managers, when you convert a strong performer you'll have the proof points you need to build a strong case for a competitive offer.

4. Providing a clearer path toward permanent employment

Challenge: In traditional long-term contract roles, conversion is not a guarantee. Employees seeking more stability will often leave for permanent positions.
Benefit: Contract to hire positions are typically designed with the potential for permanent placement in mind, offering a more defined path toward long-term stability. This transparency regarding the potential for permanent employment is a major benefit compared to traditional long-term contract roles, where conversion is never certain.

Best practices for contract to hire work arrangements

To make the most of contract to hire arrangements, it’s essential to follow best practices that ensure a smooth and successful transition.

Crafting clear and compliant offer letters

Outline key details: The contract to hire offer letter should clearly outline the terms of employment, including contract duration, specific job responsibilities, compensation details (salary, bonuses, etc.), and conditions for potential transition to a permanent role. Communicate these details clearly to the candidate from the start to avoid misunderstandings and set expectations.
Seek expert guidance: Consult with legal experts or HR professionals to ensure you comply with all relevant labor laws and regulations while protecting your company and the contractor. This includes addressing topics like benefits (if any) offered during the contract period, termination clauses for both parties, and non-compete agreements (if applicable).

Strategies for a seamless transition

Effective onboarding is crucial: A well-structured onboarding program is vital for any new hire, and contract to hire is no exception. Onboarding sets the stage for success by providing a clear understanding of company culture, values, and expectations, introducing the contractor to the team and key stakeholders, and equipping them with the necessary tools and resources to perform their job effectively.
Planning and evaluation: Establish a clear evaluation process to assess the candidate's performance throughout the contract period. Regular performance reviews provide opportunities for feedback and identify areas for improvement.
Support and development: Providing resources and support for professional development demonstrates your investment in the contractor's success and increases the likelihood of a smooth transition to a permanent role. This could include access to training programs, mentorship opportunities, or industry conferences.

Partnering with a staffing agency

Managing employment relationship: A staffing agency will manage the employment relationship during the contract phase, including important administrative tasks like payroll and employee benefits.
Performance coaching and feedback: A staffing partner can facilitate regular performance reviews and provide the contractor with constructive feedback throughout the contract.
Offer negotiation or backfilling: Staffing agencies can offer valuable expertise when extending a permanent offer to a contractor. They can also help smoothly and efficiently backfill the role with another qualified candidate if the contract to hire arrangement doesn't work out.

Hire with confidence in uncertain times

The days of simply relying on a one-size-fits-all hiring approach and hoping for the best are over. In today’s business world, companies need to be more strategic about how they staff their teams. It’s all about having a toolbox full of different solutions so you can pick the right one for the job, whether it’s a temporary need or a long-term commitment.

Contract to hire is one of those essential tools. It lets you find great people, see if they’re a good fit, and then bring them on board permanently if it’s a win-win. Companies that embrace this kind of flexibility aren’t just keeping up with the times, they’re shaping them. They’ll be the ones attracting top talent, adapting to changing markets, and leaving the competition behind. This is the future of work, and contract to hire is one of the keys to unlocking its potential.

Aquent Talent is the leading staffing and recruiting firm in marketing, creative, and design. If you’d like to explore how contract to hire can help your business, get in touch—we’re here to help.

Career Advice (43)